Just to mix things up, I’ll post two in one week. Why not? I’ve been meaning to mention the book I’m reading, New Art City by Jed Perl, as it has a way of fizzing up my brain with a bunch of random thoughts that might be lost if I don’t start writing them down. I’m reading a section about collage as it relates to nostalgia and how a synthesis of both these may have influenced apparently very different styles of painting. This just after watching Tony Bourdain’s No Reservations episode about vanishing Manhattan. It’s a big subject, the most trite thing you can say about it is this city has been in a perpetual state of nostalgia since the days of Pieter Stuyvesant. This never changes. It is the universal experience; you get off a bus from the hinterlands and shake the cornstalks out of your clothes, or you finally move out of your parents’ semi-detached in Canarsie, either way, at the moment you are young and free and starting to live in New York City someone will tell you in no uncertain terms that you missed the real fun by about ten years. It was just as true in 1915 as it is today. That said, we are shedding the good stuff at a rate unparalleled since the 1960s, to the point where, as Nick Tosches complains in the Bourdain program, New York exists primarily in our failing memories. The show itself was a very short catalog of the best of the oldest, all places the Baroness and I have on our list of essentials. When Tony visited a certain ancient, old-fashioned French institution, however, it started getting a little too close for comfort. There is nothing like this place for atmosphere, but I had to laugh when Tony insisted the food was good. Maybe Tone’s tastebuds are blown out from livin’ la vida bad-boy, but nobody goes there for the food, no matter what they tell you. You go because it’s the last of the Mohicans. In other words, nostalgia for the place even before it goes under. The segment made me fear for the health of Monsieur Robert, the owner, and by extension, the restaurant itself. A few years ago Paul Lukas had a feature in the Times about the vivacious Dames of Beef visiting this same sweet old doll of a restaurant. The resulting publicity forced a big increase in reservations that caused a lot of strain on the restaurant, and especially on Monsieur Robert, who runs a tight ship, but prefers a relaxed, unchallenging cruise to gale-force business. Which is why I’m not going to add to the feeding frenzy by typing the name here. To see this TV show in constant re-runs really worries me.
Anyway, back to book I’m reading. There is, of course, no single book to read on a subject as giant as art in New York in the middle of the Twentieth Century, and every book about any scene (large or small) will leave out great chunks that someone will find crucial, but there are some nice connections here. For instance, he starts talking about collage and nostalgia, you know what’s coming and here it is, lovely, sensitive section on Joseph Cornell; but getting from Cornell to Ellsworth Kelly is an unexpected and interesting journey. It made me think about how interested I am with the found collages stuck to the walls of all these old bars. The thing-ness of these random bits of paper, photos, football pools, placed by human hands but in the most automatic, chancy way relates strongly, I think, to Perl’s discussion of dada and collage. Applying chance to composition with the rigor of Arp can lead to beautifully serendipitous results. (Serendipitous if you believe he never cheats when he’s making a collage of bits of torn paper dropped from a height onto another blank sheet of paper. Ah, well, it wouldn’t be cheating to sort of nudge a scrap of paper when you stick it down.) I’ve always be a fan of your Nineteenth Century trompe l’oeil still life artists, your Harnett, your Peto, especially the postcard rack on the door ones. Imagine what you get with that head-on, flat aspect, but you had your local bartenders picking the subjects and arranging them! That might be where I’m headed…